The 25 Craziest Real-Life American Horror Stories

The sadistic nuns and mutated freaks on FX's American Horror Story: Asylum can't hold a blood-soaked candle to the real thing.

Not Available Lead
Complex Original

Image via Complex Original

Not Available Lead

Only three episodes into a season that spans 13, FX's American Horror Story: Asylum is already the year's wildest, most exciting free-for-all of small-screen genre entertainment. Series co-creators Ryan Murphy and Brad Falchuk clearly took the enthusiastic response to last year's inaugural American Horror Story  run and used the success to give themselves imaginative carte blanche.

Set in 1964 at the fictional Briarcliff Mental Institution, the current season—anchored by wonderfully unhinged performances from AHS returnees Jessica Lange and Lily Rabe and newcomers James Cromwell and Chloë Sevigny—isn't wasting any time. Viewers have already seen an exorcism, a deformed serial killer called Bloody Face, mutated woodland humanoids, aliens, dismemberment, and murderous nuns.

But, come on—American Horror Story: Asylum, as enjoyable as it may be, is never actually scary. Bonkers? Yes. Perversely exciting? Indeed. But terrifying? Not quite. Because nothing is as disturbing as the real thing, and, in the last 200 years, America has concealed enough serial killers and sadists to render 20 seasons' worth of American Horror Story-styled madness inconsequential.

Which is why we've combed through the most startling pages of our country's history books to compile The 25 Craziest Real-Life American Horror Stories. By the end, you'll laugh in the presence of Bloody Face and shed a tear for humanity.

RELATED: The 10 Most Horrible Real-Life Bosses
RELATED: The 50 Most Disturbing Movies
RELATED: 10 Writers with Crazier Life Stories Than William Shakespeare
RELATED: The 15 Best Movies Based on a True Story

Written by Matt Barone (@MBarone)

25. The Zodiac Killer

Not Available Interstitial

24. Andrea Yates

Not Available Interstitial

23. Richard Speck

Not Available Interstitial

22. Scott Peterson

Not Available Interstitial

21. Lizzie Borden

Not Available Interstitial

20. Christa Pike

Not Available Interstitial

19. Gary Ridgway

Not Available Interstitial

18. Ricky Kasso

Not Available Interstitial

17. Sharon Tate and the Manson family

Not Available Interstitial

16. Henry Lee Lucas

Not Available Interstitial

15. Dean Arnold Corll, the "Candy Man"/"Pied Piper"

Not Available Interstitial

14. David "Son of Sam" Berkowitz

Not Available Interstitial

13. The murder of Elyse Pahler

Not Available Interstitial

12. Richard Ramirez, "The Night Stalker"

Not Available Interstitial

11. The Black Dahlia

Not Available Interstitial

10. The Bloody Benders

Not Available Interstitial

9. Big Lurch

Not Available Interstitial

8. Ted Bundy

Not Available Interstitial

7. John Wayne Gacy

Not Available Interstitial

6. The Columbine Massacre

Not Available Interstitial

5. Dr. Henry Howard Holmes

Not Available Interstitial

4. Jeffrey Dahmer

Not Available Interstitial

3. Albert Fish

Not Available Interstitial

2. The Ripper Crew

Not Available Interstitial

1. Ed Gein

Not Available Interstitial

Latest in Pop Culture