Brittany Snow and Sophia Bush
Movie: John Tucker Must Die (2006)
Why must John Tucker die? Because John Tucker (Jesse Metcalfe) is bad. How is he bad? Because he is simultaneously scoring with Carrie (Arielle Kebbel), Heather (Ashanti), and Beth (Bush). Juggling those three makes a guy bad? More like badass. But still, from the point of view of his lovers, he's got to pay for his dirty dog-ishness. They want him humiliated, but they need an outsider to do the job, which they find in Kate (Snow). Perfect! But there's one problem. Although Kate is really, totally cute as well, she is inexperiencedâ€”she even needs a kissing lesson! Fortunately, promiscuous vegan Beth is around to give her an instructional liplock.