When: 2008-present
After missing the playoffs, Jeter had time to begin running game on the Friday Night Lights actress that October. The two were first spotted together at a Texas Longhorns football game. Though he kept tight-lipped about it at first, the relationship continued to become more public as Kelly was seen at Yankee games throughout the 2009 season and on the field with Jeter after his World Series win that October. Afterward, the two were seen vacationing in St. Barts and not long after that reports surfaced of a wedding set for November.
Smash Probability: