When: 2004
Story is Farrell smash-and-dashed Ms. Lohan after they spent a night together in L.A.'s Chateau Hotel in 2004. Colin has laid low and kept it cool about the situation since then, but Lindsay made things awkward when they ran into each other at a restaurant this past January. They've both had their share of crazy days, so this hookup would be no surprise.
Smash Probability: