Career Stats: 24,153 passing yards; 2,652 rushing yards; 183 total touchdowns (149 passing)
Awards: Three-time Pro Bowler, Two-time first-team All-Pro selection

Daunte Culpepper put together one of the best single seasons for a quarterback ever in 2004, but Peyton Manning just happened to put together the greatest single season ever (at the time) for a quarterback in the same year. Culpepper’s elite status was short-lived, but over the span of the five years he tallied three Pro Bowl appearances and two first team All-Pro selections. A serious knee injury and just plain inconsistency halted his success.