Kansas City Chiefs’ tight end Travis Kelce is an elite NFL pass catcher. But how is he with hot sauce? It turns out not very good, which Kelce admits from the jump to host Sean Evans, making for one of the most hilarious Hot Ones episodes to date. As the Pro Bowler stumbles through each wing, he discusses his favorite haunts in Kansas City, his new reality dating show on the E! Network called Catching Kelce, and his most obnoxious purchase after receiving that fat five-year, $46 million contract.

Does Kelce fumble and take the L? Or can he punch it into the endzone? Find out by watching the video above, and be sure to subscribe to First We Feast and Complex Sports on YouTube.