Stat Line: 3x All-Pro, 3x Pro Bowl, 4x Super Bowl Winner
Kickers in the NFL don’t get enough love, and there is no one more deserving of a Hall of Fame selection on this list than Adam Vinatieri. It won’t be All-Pro or Pro Bowl selections, or the fact that he sits third all-time in points scored, that defines his legacy. He’ll be remembered for drilling not one, but two game-winning field goals in the Super Bowl as a member of the Patriots in the early 2000s. In fact, his late-game heroics gave him the nickname Mr. Clutch. After helping lead the Pats to three Super Bowl victories (you can be sure Tom Brady will be thanking Vinatieri during his Hall of Fame speech), he went on to play for the Colts and is currently the only player to score 1,000 points for two teams. At 43 years of age, Vinatieri, the oldest active player in the NFL, signed a two-year contract extension with the Colts.