No. of kids / No. of baby mamas: 7/ Unknown

Collarbone injuries and substance abuse issues sidelined Charles Rogers for much of his brief and unspectacular career with the Detroit Lions, but nothing was keeping this man from putting up numbers in the bedroom. Though he only lasted three years in the NFL, Rogers has fathered seven kids with multiple women. On top of that, he was charged with paying back $6.1M of his signing bonus money back to the Lions in 2010. You don't have to be a genius to see that those numbers don't add up to anything good.