Are Justin Verlander and Kate Upton still dating? Sadly, we have no effing idea. In actuality, we have no idea if they were ever dating in the first place, because for some strange reason, neither of them wants to confirm or deny their relationship. But, whatever. What we do know is that they were reportedly spotted kicking it at the Ritz-Carlton in St. Thomas on New Year's Eve. Apparently, even there they tried to make it seem like they weren't together—"He keeps a conservative distance," a source told the New York Post—but it appears that they were both there at the same time. And, sorry, guys, but we don't think that it was just a crazy coincidence.

So, what gives? Can't Justin and Kate just give it a rest and come out as a couple? Or, at the very least, let us know. We won't tell anyone. Promise!

RELATED: The Hottest Athlete Hook-Ups of 2012

RELATED: The 100 Hottest WAGs in Sports History

[via NY Post]