5. Earl Morrall's Dilemma

Super Bowl: III (1969)
Final Score: Jets 16, Colts 7
Date: 1/12/1969

In 1968, Earl Morrall was the NFL MVP. In Super Bowl III, he was the New York Jets Super Bowl MVP. Only problem? He played for the Colts. The MVP changed the game when he missed a wide open Jimmy Orr and threw a pick to the Jets as they went on to victory. Rumor has it that Edwin M. Anzalone aka Fireman Ed was at the game assaulting Colts fans at the ripe old age of 9.