Eugene Robinson, Atlanta Falcons
Where: Super Bowl XXXIII, Miami (1999)
Incident: The same day he received the Bart Starr award for "high moral character," the safety known for his strong religious beliefs was arrested after trying to get orally blessed, offering $40 to an undercover officer for some heddy wop.
Result: Although Robinson admitted he didn't get much sleep upon being released from prison the night before, he should be thankful. At least the only time he got burned that weekend was when he allowed Rod Smith to get an 80-yard touchdown as the Denver Broncos won easily 34-19.