Darryl Talley, Buffalo Bills

Where: Super Bowl XXVII, Pasadena, California (1993)
Incident: The first big hit of Super Bowl week happened way before kickoff when Talley (pictured on the left) ran into Magic Johnson at the Sunset Boulevard hot spot, Roxbury. The linebacker thought he was being funny as he ribbed Magic Johnson, who is HIV-positive, for being in the club. Magic's bodyguard didn't, punching Talley in the face.
Result: The Bills tried to deny that the incident occurred, but several Cowboys saw Talley on the floor bloodied with no teammates coming to aid him. No crew love translated into no heart as the Cowboys thumped the Bills 52-17.