Better Manning Face
This should probably go to Cooper, but since the list is between Peyton and Eli, we'll chalk another one for Eli. True he can look dopey at times and when he puts his hands on his hips and drops his mouth open after an interception, he looks like a sassy 13-year old who just found out she didn't make the pom squad. That said, Peyton's face is bulbous, depressing, and turns crimson red during cold playoff games in Foxborough. Neither really have the eye of the tiger, but we'll take dumbfounded over miserable every time. Point, Eli.