3. Tony Mandarich

Team(s): Green Bay Packers, Indianpolis Colts
Years: 1989 - 1998
Here's an awesome idea: Let's bypass the hard work and just juice up all through college, become a beast and the No. 2 overall draft pick ahead of Deion Sanders, Derrick Thomas, and Barry Sanders. Once you get to the league, stop juicing and become the biggest NFL draft bust of all-time. Oh wait, Tony Mandarich already did this more than a decade ago.