James "The Harlem Hammer" Butler

Record and Accolades: 20-5-0 (12 KOs); Former USBA Super Middleweight Champion
Year: 2004
Crime: Murder
Sentence / Time Served: 29 years, 4 months / Currently incarcerated
When Sam Kellerman, brother of analyst Max Kellerman, was murdered in 2004, many people pointed fingers at his friend of ten years, boxer James "The Harlem Hammer" Butler. But it wasn't until two years later that Butler plead guilty to voluntary manslaughter and arson in Kellerman's death. In a case of ill-fated irony, it is believed that a hammer was the weapon used in the murder. #youcantmakethisshitup