Goat: LeBron James
Game: Game 5, 2010 Eastern Conference Semifinals
The 2010 Cleveland Cavaliers were another supposed team of destiny. For the second straight year, they owned the league's best record, had the league's MVP and set their sights on the first championship in franchise history. But in a pivotal Game 5 against their Celtic nemeses, LeBron James...well, who the hell knows? No one can say for sure that he quit, but jetting for South Beach two months later didn't do much to change anyone's mind.