Player: Magic Johnson

Current Price: $1,249.99

The downside is that this is only one shoe. The upside is how unique it is. Forget the faded signature—this PE is truly a one-of-a-kind. Made to resemble Converse's all-new ERX-400 (note the Energy Wave logo on the back) these were in reality just a dressed-up pair of Pro Leathers (check the midsole and outsole). Magic, who'd come of age in the '70s, didn't need any new-fangled tech to be the best.

Check the listing here.