Sebago Campside Saddle, $120

BNIB says: "This shoe brought back childhood memories for us with its saddle shoe inspired coloring, but it is not these emotions that put this Sebago Campside on our top 10 list. Not only are we suckers for an 'eraser' sole, but we also fall pretty hard for a pair of pulled-suede shoes. All that mixed with the black/white colorway made for one clean pair."