We have a confession to make. We will eat anything that's covered in cheese. So, while we were slightly put off by the idea of cheddar cheese and ice cream co-habitating, the idea quickly grew on us.
The American's ice cream grilled cheese is made with Tillamook Sharp Cheddar cheese ice cream that's sandwiched between two crispy pieces of brioche, each spread with peanut butter and cherry preserves. It's a crazy amalgamation of your favorite things to eat when you were seven, but laced with enough walnut liqueur to demand an adult's appreciation.