Played By: Topher Grace and Laura Prepon

Although the intention was for these friends-turned-lovers to have the same dynamic as Cory and Topanga, in actuality, Eric and Donna were just so damn boring. We're not sure if it was their disproportional body types that didn't feel right, or Eric's blah personality that didn't mix well with Donna's strong will, but something about this couple has us asking, "What were they smoking?"