When it debuted: 2011
Segment lowlight: Waxing Jets center Nick Mangold's chest. (That is a lot of chest to wax.)

Wait, we spoke too soon, this is the worst Jimmy Fallon audience game. We never want to see a man get his chest waxed, let alone as part of a TV game show. If you share a different opinion, go ahead and watch the all-time greatest Fallon chest waxing clips.