Original Air Date: February 11, 2007
Director: Mark Jean
Stars: Emma Caulfield, Barbara Niven, John Reardon
Lesson Learned: Are you overanalyzing your love life enough?

In lieu of ghosts of Christmas past, cynical radio host Ally Sims (Emma Caulfield) is presented with past, present, and future Valentine's Days by her late mentor (Barbara Niven) that returns from the grave to help her see the error of her narsty ways. Can she learn the true meaning of love before her upcoming wedding day?! We wouldn't dare spoil the surprise for you.