Maker: Planters
Peak Popularity: Mid-1990s
Watch a classic commercial here

Just so there's no confusion: We're not okay with Nutter Butters. This was our preference, the only peanut butter cookie for us, full of creamy goo. And though Nutter Butters put on a good show of affecting the outline of a peanut, the P.B. Crisps were like 3D models of real peanuts. The should end the debate.