Shay Mitchell, who plays Emily Playing-the-Fields (OK, they don’t call her that), even admits in our "Hot Complex" interview that her character has “a revolving door of girls.” Although she doesn’t land garden-variety girlfriends—Maya (Bianca Lawson) made her smoke weed, Paige (Lindsay Shaw) tried to drown her, and Samara (Claire Holt) stole her from Paige—Emily can still be a reference point for dudes having trouble charming hot chicks.