We’ve had love for comedic cutie Anna Faris ever since Scary Movie, but we’ve got to admit that her list-inspiring character, Ally Darling, leaves something to be desired. What’s Your Number? appears to have the star revisiting every last one of her previous relationships (literally) to see if any of her dudes have become more appealing over the years, possibly evolving into her soulmate.

As ridiculous as some of her fellas may seem, the premise that a girl would actually initiate this undertaking makes her seem crazier than the rest of her exes by far. Plus, come on—one look at the trailer makes it blatantly obvious she’s going to realize that her boo, a best friend played by Chris Evans, has been right under her nose all along. Place your bets now.