Most Dominant Year: 2003

The 33-year-old Bears linebacker may be slowing down a bit these days, but he's still a solid middle linebacker, and he can play for our team any day. In his heyday, Urlacher regularly garnered high-80s Speed ratings, and he rivaled Ray Lewis for top middle linebacker honors. He fit the mold of a Madden player, too, flying to the ball and regularly making big plays.