Most Dominant Year: 2011

With Brett Favre out of the picture in Green Bay, Rodgers has gradually emerged to become one of the league's preeminent signal-callers. EA devs have always respected him and given him solid ratings, but 2011 could be Rodgers' virtual coming-out party. Rodgers has a 98 Overall rating, he can make every pass, and oh, he can run a bit, too (79 Speed). Who needs Brett Favre? Not gamers, who can get buy just fine with Aaron.