14. PENELOPE ANN MILLER AS MARGO LANELove interest: Lamont Cranston a.k.a. The Shadow
Cranston's Shadow alter-ego (played by Alec Baldwin in the 1994 flick The Shadow) is gifted with the ability to influence minds and bend people's perceptions. But this proves ineffective with New York socialite Margo Lane (Miller), not just because she has a presumably impenetrable arrogant demeanor, but because she's also a telepath who could read every single thing he was thinking. Frankly, we supported his decision to end their relationship. We don't find blackmail particularly sexy.