When: 2006 to 2007
They met at a Dublin bar during Christmas and started dating shortly thereafter. Sadly, there were reports that a few months later McDonnell's ex-boyfriend, John Marc Knight, committed suicide after having trouble dealing with McDonnell dating Farrell. Not that we're, um, suggesting there was any correlation between the two events. Soon reports were flying around that she was pregnant, but her reps shut those down, and now she's just another pretty girl on this list.
Smash Probability: