When: 2003 to 2006
Jeter and Minnillo began their relationship as the TRL host was picking up fame and Jeter was officially named captain of the Yankees. Their on-again and off-again relationship publicly began as the pair was first seen together courtside at a Knicks game. Though the pair was pictured later on at a party, the details of their relationship were always kept on the DL. The couple separated in 2006 with Minnillo starting her relationship with Nick Lachey after his divorce from Jessica Simpson, and Jeter seeing Jessica Biel. Vanessa who?
Smash Probability: