When: 2004
The actress and singer was supposedly seen leaving a Christmas party with Jeter that year. But Johannson quickly shot down the rumors, saying she had been in a relationship with musician and actor Jared Leto for months and that her and Jeter had simply shown up to a mutual friend's party. I guess we'll believe her, but we all know that holiday parties usually end messy. And no, that's not eggnog.
Smash Probability: