When: 2001
The 7th Heaven actress and Mariah Carey back-up singer was invited by A-Rod to the 2001 All-Star game, where he introduced her to Jeter. Less than two months after the introduction Joy switched teams and was soon catching Jeter. Er, catching for Jeter. A-Rod said he was cool with it. Riiiighhht. Sloppy seconds? Maybe. The girl may be trifey but like nearly every other girl on this list that body is wifey material.
Smash Probability:

Also Watch