Movies: Martha Marcy May Marlene (2011), Silent House (2012)

It’s too early to label Elizabeth Olsen an official “scream queen”. Despite her flirtations with becoming scary movie royalty, the youngest Olsen sister has also shaken things up, with a lead role in the indie rom-com Liberal Arts and talks pinning her to Spike Lee’s Oldboy remake (for which we fear she'd make this list). Regardless, though, there’s one thing that Hollywood can’t ever take away from us genre heads, no matter how big she gets: Thanks to Martha Marcy May Marlene and Silent House, Lizzie Olsen showed horror fans love first.