34. Gears of War (2006)
Final Level: Pale Horse
Why It Sucked: For the amount of buildup in this game, we couldn't have been more disappointed by the ending. In the grand scheme of this series, practically nothing happens inthe first Gears; it's not even until the very end of the final cutscene that they reveal there even is a Locust queen.
How We Would End It: Blowing up those tunnels felt hollow in the long run; this game should have ended with a much more meaningful victory. That's what happens when half the game is filler, though.