19. Troy Polamalu
Most Dominant Year: 2010
The Steelers safety shared the cover with Cardinals receiver Larry Fitzgerald in Madden 10, the first time a pair of players landed on the cover. But even before that, the wild-haired Samoan had ranked as one of the game's finest players. Polamalu was always a strong fast hitter, capable of jarring the ball from opposing ballcarriers, and he had solid enough hands to get a few interceptions, too. Gamers love controlling him and roving the passing lanes for interceptions and big hits.