44. Steve McNair
Most Dominant Year: 2001
Have you figured out our love for running QBs yet? No button combination of Franchise addition or graphical improvement has revolutionized Madden as much as the scrambling QB, and it all started with McNair in 2001. The Titans signal-caller could roll out and draw the defense, and thanks to a few unrealistic design decisions, he could throw incredibly accurately on the run. He was as fast as a tailback, with the arm of a Pro Bowler.