1. Michael Vick
Most Dominant Year: 2004
And it's not even close. Sure, the rest of the guys on this list are great, but not a single one forced developers to revamp the game the way Vick did. Before Vick landed on the cover in Madden 2004, defense was a three-button affair. But after the Falcons QB dominated the online gridiron, forcing EA to make changes, introducing the Hit Stick and slapping a defensive player, LB Ray Lewis, on the cover of Madden 2005. And yet, very little has changed seven years later. Vick is now with the Eagles, and he's again the game's most dangerous QB.