35. Marvin Harrison
Most Dominant Year: 2003
Much like his Colts teammate Peyton Manning, Harrison never really had that one overwhelming characteristic. He wasn't the biggest wideout, and he was never the fastest. But he always ran crisp routes, and he never ever dropped passes he should catch. That made him a reliable target until his retirement in 2008. And nobody ever minded having him on their Madden teams, either.