49. Devin Hester
Most Dominant Year: 2008
Aside from a few dynamic punt returns, Hester's never made much of an impact in the real NFL, and he's struggled to make an impact as a receiver. But boy, can he jet in the video game. Four years ago, he even redefined Madden, earning a 100 speed rating, the highest in series history, and that made him tremendously useful in Madden 08. That extra tick of speed made him a tough one-on-one cover, occasionally forcing opposing teams to roll a safety his way.