40. Charles Woodson
Most Dominant Year: 2008
For a Madden corner, Woodson isn't particularly fast, and he's not terribly strong. But EA's always granted him high Catch and Awareness ratings, and that's always made him one of the best cover corners in the game. And if you're someone who loves confusing opponents and playing actual Cover-2 zones, you love Woodson, because he's one of the best zone CBs in the game.