23. Brett Favre
Most Dominant Year: 2000
If it seems as if Favre has been around forever, it's most likely because he has. The legendary QB broke into the league in 1991 and retired (we think) before this season. That's 20 years of service, and he's the only QB in the history of the game to land on the Madden cover (he made it in '09) in one uniform then get switched to another. Favre was on the cover as a Packer, but after signing with the Jets, EA started releasing a second box with Favre as a Jet. Favre has never been the game's top-ranked QB, but he always brings a cannon arm.