Date: June 5, 2009
Backstory: Heather Megan Snively responded to a Craigslist ad posted by Korena Roberts in search of baby clothes for her unborn child. After a week of communication, Roberts tricked the soon-to-be mother into her home where she cut Snively's baby from her wound, killing her and the newborn in the process. Roberts lied to friends about being pregnant and had plans of passing the baby off as her own.
Punishment: A guilty plea wouldn't save this monster as four counts of aggravated murder equal a life prison sentence.