Designer: Melanie Hein
Click Here To Buy It Now At Turtles Soup, $3.85

This card is a great way to get that, "Haha, you're joking... you better be joking" look from your girl. The owner of Turtles Soup, Melanie, has always had a knack for craft. As a child, she created heartfelt gifts for her family and friends and was constantly told that she should pursue her talent. Her Etsy shop opened on Dec. 31, 2012 as part of her New Year's resolution, and it's still going strong.