Sport Played: NFL
Year: 2011
Crime: Possessed a bottle of Viagra in Gainesville, Fla. with no prescription

If you were riding around in your car with an unmarked bottle of unprescribed Viagra, you would think that you would do everything in your power to avoid having the police find it. Not Murphy. He got pulled over one night for having the music in his car turned up too loud. Then, he wouldn't show police his ID. And finally, he refused to allow a cop to place him under arrest. As a result of all of this, the police found his unmarked bottle of Viagra—which he said was unmarked “because he did not want his girlfriend to know he had a prescription for it”—and threw him in jail. Oh, what a night.