Sport Played: NFL
Year: 2010
Crime: Stole a bunch of maple bars from a donut shop in Renton, Wash. at 3 a.m. before the store opened

During his time with the Seahawks, the wide receiver became a big fan of the maple bars that a shop called Top Pot Doughnuts makes. “They're irresistible,” he said in 2010. So irresistible that, early one Saturday morning, Tate and a friend decided to break into Top Pot four hours before the shop was set to open in order to grab a bunch of the bars. Tate later called it a “foolish mistake” and, fortunately for him, no charges were ever filed. But the incident became so infamous in the Renton area that Top Pot wished Tate well when he left the Seahawks this offseason and signed with the Lions.