Sport: Football
Criminal History: Armed robbery, aggravated robbery, felony alluding, weapons charges
Time Behind Bars: Three years

Maurice Clarett could have been an Ohio State legend but ended up, like most All-American Buckeyes, a cautionary tale. After scoring 18 touchdowns his freshman year, Mo was involved in a public coaching dispute, an academic fraud scandal, and falsified a police report before being dismissed from OSU. You know, the kind of stuff that gets you kicked out of school early so you can go make millions in the league. Cha-ching!

In 2006, Clarett was implicated in several armed robberies. Then, later that year, he led police on a high-speed chase. When Clarett was obtained (after an alleged violent struggle with officers) police discovered one hell of a weekend getaway package: a loaded AK-47, two handguns and an open bottle of Grey Goose.