What stans think: Here's the real GOAT.
What haters think: What has he won lately?
What realists think: He and Bill Belichick combine to make a nigh unstoppable QB/Coaching monster in the NFL.

It's up to you to decide what's more important: Records or championships. But the real question should be: If Peyton was in New England would he have three (or more) titles? And if Brady was in Indy would he, the Colts, and now the Broncos, have been as consistently solid as they have throughout Manning's tenure in the NFL? Those are reasonable questions which is why they don't belong anywhere near an Internet debate. Just type cheapshots 140 characters at a time and always finish with a #dick. Argument. Won.