Years: 1995, 1998-2005
Team(s): Philadelphia Eagles, Minnesota Vikings, Jacksonville Jaguars, Miami Dolphins, New York Jets
Drafted: Undrafted
Starts: 60

We have to give Jay Fiedler some credit: he's way smarter than us. The Dartmouth College grad certainly made the most out of his NFL chance, starting 60 games and in 2002 being inducted into the National Jewish Museum Sports Hall of Fame. Unfortunately, he wasn't actually that good. His Dolphins teams that made the playoffs did so despite their quarterback, riding standout defensive efforts to compensate for a man who threw 19 interceptions in the only season in which he played 16 games.