Date: 9/6/1989
Game: 1990 World Cup Qualifying, England vs. Sweden
Watch it here

By the end of England's World Cup qualifer against Sweden, Butcher looked more like a serial killer than a footballer. A collision early in the game created a gash on his head, which England's trainers haphazardly bandaged. Their work proved to be useless, because Butcher kept on heading the ball, thus opening up his wounds. His no-nonsense work in central defense earned England a 0-0 draw and a birth in the 1990 World Cup, but it left him bloodied and maniacal looking. (Patrick Bateman, anyone?) No amount of bleach was going to get THAT blood stain out.