Date: 1/27/1991
Super Bowl: XXV
Matchup: Bills vs. Giants
Location: Tampa, FL

Poor, poor Buffalo. In four years, they managed to lose four consecutive Super Bowls despite having a Hall of Fame quarterback, running back, and coach. If only they had a Pro Bowl kicker—oh wait, they did! Scott Norwood, who made the Pro Bowl in 1988 with the Bills, lined up what looked to be a makeable 47-yard field goal that would have won Super Bowl XXV against the New York Giants. Unfortunately for the Bills and their fans, Norwood pushed the kick wide right, sending the Giants into delirium putting his team into utter despair and himself into the pantheon of all-time biggest goats in the history of sports.